This post is part of our NORDP 2016 Conference Reports. These reports capture the take-home points from a variety of sessions presented at the NORDP Annual Meeting in Orlando.
Session Scribe: Kristin Wetherbee
Presenter: Marjorie Piechowski
Key points from the session:
- The U.S. Dept. of Education isn’t very consistent with funding opportunities. Programs may not be offered every year and there are few established due dates. Formatting and page limit requirements can vary. Also, some submissions must go through grants.gov while other must go through the U.S. Department of Education’s e-grants system.
- Notices are announced via the Federal Register and the U.S. Dept. of Education website with a minimum 30 day notice (often, only 30 days’ notice is given).
- Proposals should cite literature from the National Clearinghouse which holds documents about the current state of research.
- Proposal components:
- Personnel – must adequately describe role and credentials relative to the proposal
- Project design and need – often weighed most heavily by reviewers
- Adequacy of resources – need to address the specifics of what you’re asking for (cost per student, cost share, institutional resources)
- Evaluation – often weighted heavily, up to 20% of total points. The Department seems to prefer external evaluators so you must provide excellent justification if using your own evaluation tool.
- Special and competitive priorities – these may or may not be required. Bonus points may be given for addressing them so don’t make reviewers hunt for this language; state clearly and boldly in the proposal.
- Program officers don’t have to be experts in the field and some PI’s have found that program officer comments are in direct conflict with what the review committee wants.
What did you hear at this presentation that surprised you?
The consistency of the Department’s lack of consistency.
- U.S. Federal Register: https://www.federalregister.gov/
- What Works IES Clearinghouse: http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/
- National Center for Education Statistics: https://nces.ed.gov/
- Educational Resources Information Center (ERIC) and Other Clearinghouses: